A phone advertised as “free” is not necessarily the cheapest option. This worksheet shows how to compare the full cost of buying a phone outright, using financing, accepting a carrier promotion, or choosing a SIM-free device. You will learn which figures to collect, how to account for plan costs, trade-in credits, activation fees, taxes, and early cancellation risk, and how to repeat the calculation when a deal changes.
Overview
The useful comparison is not the advertised monthly device payment. It is the total cost of owning and connecting the phone for the period you actually expect to keep it.
A simple total ownership calculation is:
Total cost = upfront costs + device payments + required plan costs + fees − genuine credits and discounts
For a fair comparison, calculate every option over the same period. If one offer requires 24 months and another requires 36 months, choose a comparison period that reflects your likely usage or calculate both periods separately. A three-year carrier promotion may look inexpensive during its credit period but become less attractive if you usually change phones after two years.
Compare these common purchase routes:
| Purchase route | What to include | Main question |
|---|---|---|
| Buy outright | Sale price, tax, shipping, and compatible plan | Does the lower commitment justify the larger upfront payment? |
| Manufacturer or retailer financing | Deposit, monthly payments, interest, fees, and plan | Is the financing genuinely low-cost, or does it add interest and restrictions? |
| Carrier promotion | Device payments, monthly credits, plan premium, activation, and trade-in requirements | What must remain true for every promotional credit to arrive? |
| SIM-free or unlocked phone | Phone price, tax, accessories, and chosen SIM-only plan | Does flexibility and easier switching outweigh a higher purchase price? |
Do not treat a promotional credit as an immediate discount unless the terms say it is applied immediately. Many offers reduce the bill over time. If you leave the carrier, upgrade early, fail to meet an eligibility condition, or lose a required line, future credits may stop. Verify the specific offer before purchasing; terms can differ by phone, plan, account, and retailer.
How to estimate
Start by creating one row for each deal and one column for each cost. Use the same ownership period for every row.
- Choose the comparison period. Use the time you realistically expect to keep the phone, or the length of the longest commitment. Record a second result if you are unsure.
- Record the phone cost. Add the cash price or the full financed balance. A monthly device payment alone can hide the amount still owed if you cancel early.
- Calculate financing. Multiply the monthly device payment by the number of payments included in your comparison period. Add interest, setup charges, and any final payment. Subtract only a discount that is guaranteed under the stated terms.
- Add plan costs. Multiply the required monthly plan cost by the number of months. If the promotion requires a more expensive plan than your normal choice, record the difference as a deal cost.
- Add one-time charges. Include activation, upgrade, delivery, SIM, and other unavoidable fees. Keep taxes separate if they are calculated differently or paid upfront.
- Subtract trade-in value carefully. Use the value you are actually likely to receive, not the highest advertised amount. Note whether the value arrives as an instant reduction, account credit, or monthly bill credit.
- Calculate the exit cost. If you might leave before the term ends, estimate the remaining device balance and remove any credits you would no longer receive. This reveals the cost of changing carriers early.
A reusable worksheet can look like this:
| Input | Deal A | Deal B | Deal C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comparison months | |||
| Upfront phone cost | |||
| Total device payments | |||
| Required plan cost | |||
| Activation and other fees | |||
| Tax and shipping | |||
| Trade-in and promotional credits | |||
| Total ownership cost | |||
| Cost per month |
To calculate cost per month, divide total ownership cost by the comparison period. This is useful for budgeting, but it should not replace the total. A deal with a low monthly figure may still require a substantial upfront payment or a long commitment.
Inputs and assumptions
Before comparing deals, write down the assumptions that could change the result.
- Plan baseline: Identify the plan you would choose without the promotion. The relevant cost is often the difference between the required plan and that baseline, not the entire plan bill.
- Promotion duration: Record how many billing cycles provide credits and whether credits begin immediately or after a delay.
- Eligibility: Check whether the offer requires a new line, a specific trade-in, a particular plan, automatic payments, or a qualifying account status.
- Ownership and lock status: Confirm when the phone becomes eligible for use with another carrier. See the unlocked versus carrier-locked phone guide before treating a carrier deal as flexible.
- Trade-in condition: Estimate the likely grade, including screen damage, battery condition, activation locks, and missing accessories. The phone trade-in value guide can help you prepare a realistic value.
- Replacement timing: A promotion can be economical if you keep the phone for its entire credit period and expensive if you replace it early. Include both scenarios when your plans are uncertain.
Also account for costs that are easy to overlook. A phone may need a case, screen protector, compatible charger, or extra storage. These purchases are not always deal-breakers, but they should be included when one option requires accessories that another already includes. For charging compatibility, use the USB-C charging guide. For protection, compare materials and fit in the screen protector guide.
Worked examples
The following figures are illustrative inputs, not current offers. Their purpose is to show the method.
Suppose a buyer compares three 24-month options for the same phone:
| Option | Illustrative calculation | Total |
|---|---|---|
| Buy unlocked | Phone at 600 + plan at 25 × 24 + 20 fee | 1,220 |
| Finance with a lower-cost plan | Device at 25 × 24 + plan at 25 × 24 + 20 fee | 1,220 |
| Carrier promotion | Device at 30 × 24 + required plan at 55 × 24 + 40 fee − 600 credits | 1,440 |
In this example, the carrier promotion has a large device credit but still costs more because the required plan is 30 per month higher than the lower-cost plan. Over 24 months, that plan difference adds 720, which outweighs the apparent phone discount. The unlocked and financed options have the same total under these assumptions, but they differ in cash flow: buying unlocked requires more money at the start, while financing leaves a monthly obligation.
Now test an early-exit scenario for the carrier promotion at month 12. Remove the remaining promotional credits, add the unpaid device balance if it is due, and include any replacement phone cost. If the result is substantially higher than expected, the promotion is best suited to someone confident they will remain with that carrier for the full term.
For a broader comparison of sale prices, financing, bundles, and carrier costs, see Phone Deals Explained. The same worksheet can also compare a refurbished phone, provided you include its warranty, condition, battery expectations, and any necessary accessories. The refurbished phone checklist covers those checks.
When to recalculate
Recalculate the worksheet whenever a price, term, or personal assumption changes. The most important triggers are a new promotion, a different required plan, a change in trade-in value, a revised financing term, or a decision to leave your current carrier.
It is also worth checking before major shopping periods, when upgrading an existing line, and when a “free phone” advertisement appears. Save a copy of the offer terms and note the date, because promotional credits and eligibility rules may change. If you are comparing phone deals this week, do not rely on an old calculation simply because the phone model is the same.
Before ordering, complete this short final check:
- Set the same comparison period for every option.
- Confirm the required plan and calculate its premium over your normal plan.
- Separate immediate discounts from future bill credits.
- Write down the payoff amount and lost credits if you leave early.
- Use a realistic trade-in value and keep proof of the device condition.
- Add activation, tax, shipping, accessories, and any unavoidable fees.
- Compare total cost first, then use monthly cost to assess affordability.
The cheapest phone deal is the one that remains affordable and useful under your real plans, not merely the one with the lowest advertised device payment. Keep this worksheet with your purchase records and update it whenever the deal or your expected ownership period changes.